Winter Springs shuts down talk of dissolving police department

Commissioner Paul Diaz wanted to have a cost comparison discussion of Seminole County taking over the police department. The mayor said that talking about shuttering the police department before the Amendment 3 vote could cause officers to leave.

The Winter Springs City Commission declined to talk about dissolving its police department Monday. 

Florida constitutional Amendment 3 is on the ballot next week which, if passed, would increase the property tax exemption to $250,000 in two years. That would potentially cut $4.1 million from Winter Springs’ city budget. 

Though the Seminole County Sheriff’s Department is charged with protecting the county, schools and other duties, it has never taken over a city’s police department. – Photo by Isaac Benjamin Babcock

Commissioner Paul Diaz, who has been vocal in his support of Amendment 3, said the city should look at a cost comparison of what it would cost to have Seminole County provide law enforcement in Winter Springs. 

“Nothing that was being proposed by me tonight endangers any department, changes any funding, changes any job for any officer,” Diaz said. “The conversation is strictly a financial conversation, which is the role of this commission.”

But Winter Springs Mayor Kevin McCann asked for a vote to end the discussion before it even happened. McCann said just the discussion of dissolving the department can cause officers to leave. 

“Listen, after election day and Amendment 3, we’re going to have to have a lot of conversations if that passes,” McCann said. “But to do so now is undue stress to the people that protect us and the damage that can be done. I’m asking for a motion to stop this conversation dead in its tracks, right now.”

Deputy Mayor Cade Resnick made the motion. It passed 4-1, with only Diaz voting against it. Resnick, McCann and Commissioner Victoria Bruce are all up for reelection. 

“I hope you understand the signal that we’ve sent,” McCann said, speaking of the city’s police force. “The vast majority of this Commission stands behind you. We will continue to stand behind you. You deserve our loyalty and our support, and you will have it till my last day.”

Abe Aboraya is a Report for America corps member. 

Support critical, local news you rely on to stay informed, connected and empowered.

Monthly Yearly One-time

Choose a monthly amount

Hometown Hero
$10 /month
Hometown Hero
$120 /year
Hometown Hero
$60 /one-time
Rooster Society
$30 /month
Rooster Society
$360 /year
Rooster Society
$360 /one-time
Custom Amount
$
/month

Please contact us directly for donations over $5000

Please enter an amount of $5 or above.

Minimum amount of $5
Custom Amount
$
/year

Please contact us directly for donations over $5000

Please enter an amount of $5 or above.

Minimum amount of $5
Custom Amount
$
/one-time

Please contact us directly for donations over $5000

Please enter an amount of $5 or above.

Minimum amount of $5

Please select an option

Thank you for your support!

Author

Abe is the Local Government Accountability Reporter for Oviedo Community News and is a Report for America corps member. His work has appeared on NPR, ProPublica, Kaiser Health News and StoryCorps. He spent 2018 investigating post-traumatic stress disorder in first responders, and investigated why paramedics didn’t enter Pulse nightclub to bring out victims. In 2018, the Florida Associated Press Professional Broadcasters Contest awarded that series second place in the investigative category and first place in the public affairs category. Aboraya holds a bachelor’s degree in journalism from the University of Central Florida. His first journalism job in 2007 was covering the city of Winter Springs in Seminole County. A father of two, Aboraya spends his free time reading and writing fiction and enjoying his second home in the Hyrule kingdom.

Reach Abe by email at abeaboraya@oviedocommunitynews.org

Are you in the know? Get our newsletter. 

Close the CTA