Seminole County parents fear ‘militarization,’ guns in schools

Parents speak out about guns in schools at School Board meeting as Sheriff’s Department School Safety Director tries to quell fears.

Residents and parents expressed their concerns over putting more guns in schools by arming teachers as safety measures to combat school gun violence at the Seminole County School Board’s meeting last Thursday. 

The comments came amidst the board’s unanimous approval for the safety recommendations made by the county’s school safety specialist as per the requirements of Florida Statute 1006.07.

Ron Shaw, Seminole County Sheriff’s Office captain and school safety director, said the assessments made for the recommendations have offered “valuable insight” into current campus safety measures and areas of improvement. 

“Our top priority, as always, is ensuring safety and security by students, staff and visitors across all school campuses,” Shaw said. “This plan has already made significant strides in improving campus security, but there’s still work to be done to address the evolving safety needs here … the key areas of focus for the upcoming year include strategic fencing, access control, school safety technology, legal management platforms, security ways and radio system upgrades.”

The meeting’s public input section saw multiple residents approach the board to urge members to take action to keep guns out of Seminole County schools, for both students and teachers. 

guns in schools
Parents recently expressed worry to the Seminole County School Board about teachers carrying guns in schools. – Photo courtesy Pixabay

Seminole County resident JJ Holmes, whose younger sister attends school within the county, told the board that the “angry voices” of those calling for measures such as instituting a Guardian program within the county should be considered as “just a loud minority.”

“I trust you to do the right thing to make sure our schools are safe by only listening to the experts,” Holmes said. 

Established by the Florida legislature following the 2018 Marjory Stoneman Douglas school shooting, the controversial Guardian program allows for school boards to let teachers and other school staff carry firearms in certain situations as a means of defense. 

A total of 53 counties throughout the state are listed as currently participating in the program, including Orange, Brevard and Osceola County. Seminole County schools, while not a part of the Guardian program, have maintained the presence of SROs in recent years. 

Seminole County resident Fiona Shannon said she supports the current safety plan already in practice which dictates all elementary, middle and high schools within Seminole County retain school resource officers on school grounds. 

Shannon, who said she’s been advocating against arming teachers since 2018, agrees with having an armed and trained SRO in county schools but said she disagrees with those calling for measures such as armed military veterans to take up similar safety positions.  

“Our SROs are fully trained law enforcement, and they are the only ones who should be armed in our schools,” Shannon said. “I hear some people advocating for armed military veterans in our schools. As the mother of a recently retired army captain, this is not the answer, as he has told me over and over, most veterans are not trained in up close armed combat with firearm usage, not to mention combat with young children.” 

Veterans with PTSD issues are also a concern, Shannon said, one that should be considered when investing in keeping school children safe.

“The last thing our kids want is the militarization of our schools,” Shannon said. “We don’t want our schools to resemble prisons. We want our schools to remain a safe place for us.”

Rick Francis, chief of the department of school safety for the Seminole County Sheriff’s Office, said the matter of student safety was a paramount consideration for the department. 

“We are responsible for the most vulnerable, something that we take very, very seriously,” Francis said. “We asked many, many times what a safe school is, and this is probably the best definition that I can think of, is where students can learn in a welcoming environment free of intimidation and fear.”

Francis described the department’s approach to school safety as being “robust, holistic and layered”, with typical security measures being paired with a focus on a school’s culture and climate. 

“One of the things that is very important to comment on when it comes to school safety is it is a constant balance,” Francis said. “And as mentioned earlier, we are constantly leveraging school safety technology best practices. But one of the things that we try to do is we don’t want our schools to look like prisons.”

Ray McClory, a Seminole County resident for nearly 25 years, asked the board to consider some of the issues that could arise by allowing for a guardian program in the county’s schools in the future. 

“We all should have only fully trained law enforcement officers in our schools with guns, nobody else, and this is especially true for teachers,” McClory said. “The biggest problem I see with this is if there is an incident, law enforcement comes in, sees a person with a gun. Now, is that an armed teacher, is that a guardian or is that the perpetrator?”

McClory added that distributing firearm safety and education information would be another easy step for the board to take to help prevent gun violence. 

“What we need to do is create a safe atmosphere in the schools, not an atmosphere of fear, which will hinder learning,” McClory said. “One of the easiest things to do would be to have the board send out letters to the parents explaining the Florida laws about securing guns … how many times do you hear about school shootings where the students got the gun from parents, whether it was a gift … or they got a gun that was unsecured?”

Concerns over student proximity to firearms in classroom situations were also discussed, with Seminole County resident Kelly Schumer telling the board she feared for the life of her six-year-old autistic son, a student at Wekiva Elementary School in the ESE program, due to a lack of consideration for the safety of special education students in emergency planning. 

“My son and his peers often have meltdowns during code red drills, and their crying is the only sound that can be heard in the halls,” Schumer said, pausing to wipe away tears. “Which would act as a beacon to a shooter should they come into the school. All to say that special education kids are uniquely vulnerable during shootings and according to our SRO, there are no procedures in place to help high-need students during shootings.”

Schumer added that anyone proposing to arm teachers should consider that special education students who may struggle with impulse control, emotional regulation or following directions may be in even more danger through the arming of their teacher or aid. 

“Before any caveats are made about not allowing special education teachers to have guns, I want to remind everyone that these students are not limited to their classrooms but go around the school to specials, recess, P.E. and more,” Schumer said. “They are mainstreamed and spend time in grade level classrooms. Guns are not safe around these students, period. They deserve to be full members of their school communities, and to be given as good a chance of surviving a shooting as their peers.” 

Concerns over gun violence within schools continue to persist, from the county and beyond, with Seminole County resident Deana Schott describing the situation as one that impacts both children and parents at home and beyond. 

“Increasing gun violence has become a very widespread issue impacting communities all over the United States,” Schott said. “It causes lasting trauma and cascading consequences for children, families and communities. It’s not just what happens here, it’s when they hear about it happening in other places as well.”

The Seminole County School Board’s next meeting will take place Tuesday, Nov. 19 at 5:30 p.m. at 400 E. Lake Mary Blvd. in Sanford. 

Support critical, local news you rely on to stay informed, connected and empowered.

Monthly Yearly One-time

Choose a monthly amount

Hometown Hero
$10 /month
Hometown Hero
$120 /year
Hometown Hero
$60 /one-time
Rooster Society
$30 /month
Rooster Society
$360 /year
Rooster Society
$360 /one-time
Custom Amount
$
/month

Please contact us directly for donations over $5000

Please enter an amount of $5 or above.

Minimum amount of $5
Custom Amount
$
/year

Please contact us directly for donations over $5000

Please enter an amount of $5 or above.

Minimum amount of $5
Custom Amount
$
/one-time

Please contact us directly for donations over $5000

Please enter an amount of $5 or above.

Minimum amount of $5

Please select an option

Thank you for your support!

Author

Kathryn covers Winter Springs, covering the city’s public meetings and important matters in the community. She is a local journalist with experience covering local government meetings and issues that impact the residents she serves. She’s a University of Central Florida graduate with a bachelors degree in print/digital journalism, as well as a certificate in public and professional writing. She previously served as the assistant news editor for the UCF student newspaper NSM Today.

When she’s not working, she likes to curl up with her cats and a good book.

Close the CTA

OCN's NewsMatch fundraiser is underway!

 

Independent, unbiased news is hard to find & that's what you get from OCN. But it will only continue with your support. Give now & NewsMatch will DOUBLE it.